A personal injury or liability claims, one of the most critical—and often elusive—pieces of information is the at-fault party’s insurance policy limits. Knowing how much coverage is available can drastically affect legal strategy, client expectations, and settlement decisions.
While insurance companies aren’t always forthcoming with this data, seasoned attorneys and legal professionals have a toolkit of techniques to uncover it. This process, known as policy limit tracing, blends legal know-how, investigative tactics, and persistence.
Let’s break down the tools and techniques the pros use to trace insurance policy limits effectively.
Why Policy Limit Tracing Matters
Policy Limit Tracing represents the maximum amount an insurer will pay on behalf of its insured. If a plaintiff’s damages far exceed the available coverage, knowing the limits early can help guide whether to settle quickly, pursue additional defendants, or consider underinsured motorist coverage. It also helps:
Avoid over-litigating low-value claims
Identify cases where excess judgments and bad faith claims may arise
Strategically time negotiations for maximum leverage
Formal Requests to Insurance Companies
The most common (and often successful) technique is a direct written request to the liable party’s insurance carrier.
What Pros Include in the Request:
Details of the accident (date, time, location)
Client identification (name, date of birth, injuries sustained)
A request for all applicable liability and umbrella policy limits
A deadline for response (typically 20-30 days)
Legal citation if the jurisdiction requires disclosure
Pro Tip:
Attach supporting documents like police reports or medical records to show the claim is legitimate. Some states, like California and Florida, require insurers to disclose policy information within a specific timeframe.
Leveraging State Statutory Rights
Certain states have enacted laws that require disclosure of Policy Limit Tracing upon a written request. Knowing the statutes in your jurisdiction is a power move.
Key Statutes:
California Insurance Code § 791.13
Florida Statute § 627.4137
New York Insurance Law § 2601-a (recently passed)
These laws typically require an affidavit from the claimant or attorney confirming the legitimacy of the claim, prompting insurers to respond with:
Named insureds
Coverage limits
Excess or umbrella policies
Policy numbers and effective dates
Policy Disclosure via Litigation Discovery
If a case moves into litigation, attorneys have powerful discovery tools at their disposal:
Discovery Tools Used:
Interrogatories: Ask defendants to disclose insurance information under oath.
Requests for Production: Request copies of insurance declarations and policy documents.
Initial Disclosures: Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26, parties must disclose insurance agreements that may cover a judgment.
Pro Tip:
Don’t wait too long—get insurance questions into your first round of discovery to keep pressure on early.
Subpoenas and Court Orders
If the insurer or defendant refuses voluntary disclosure, a subpoena duces tecum can compel them to produce insurance documents. In some cases, a motion to compel or a court order may be necessary.
Courts usually favor transparency when the plaintiff demonstrates that the information is reasonably calculated to lead to admissible evidence.
Using Public Records and Claims Databases
Public records can sometimes be a goldmine for insurance information, especially in complex or repeat litigation cases.
Where Pros Look:
Prior court cases: Lawsuits against the same defendant may contain policy details in pleadings or settlements.
State insurance departments: Some states require reporting of claims over certain thresholds.
Police accident reports: Occasionally list insurer names and policy numbers.
Claims databases: Some pros use private investigation firms or access subscription-based claims tracking systems (e.g., ISO ClaimSearch) to find potential coverages.
Settlement Negotiation Tactics
Sometimes, Policy Limit Tracing surfaces during negotiations, especially if damages exceed what the insurer is likely to pay.
Tactics Include:
Submitting a settlement demand close to or above the policy limit to trigger disclosure.
Framing the demand in a way that suggests a bad faith risk if the insurer fails to settle within policy limits.
Including language in the demand that creates a record, the insurer had a clear chance to settle within limits.
This can set the stage for an excessive judgment or bad-faith claim later.
Working with Your Own Client’s Coverage
In uninsured or underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) cases, your own client’s policy becomes part of the tracing puzzle.
Make sure to:
Request a certified declarations page from your client’s carrier.
Determine whether stacking is allowed under state law.
Investigate potential umbrella or excess coverage that they may not even know about.
Investigative Tools and Private Research
When traditional methods don’t work, the pros get creative.
Investigative Techniques:
Hiring private investigators with access to insurance lookup tools.
Running asset searches on the defendant to see if excess recovery is possible beyond policy limits.
Social media and business records: Businesses often boast about being “fully insured,” which may lead to deeper inquiries into their policies.
Building Pressure with a Time-Limited Demand
A favorite tool among veteran attorneys is the time-limited policy that limits demand. This technique puts the insurer in a position where failing to respond within the deadline could expose them to bad faith liability.
Make sure the demand:
Is in writing and well-documented
Specifies the injuries and evidence clearly
Offers to settle within policy limits
Includes a firm deadline for response
Challenges Pros Navigate
Even experienced attorneys run into roadblocks:
Uncooperative insurers delaying disclosure
Multiple layers of coverage (primary, excess, umbrella)
Unclear statutes in certain jurisdictions
Cross-border cases with conflicting laws
Knowing how to pivot between strategies and escalate appropriately is what separates routine practitioners from seasoned litigators.
Final Thoughts
Policy limit tracing is both a science and an art. While there’s no guaranteed formula, the combination of legal expertise, persuasive communication, and strategic discovery usually does the trick. The most successful attorneys know when to be patient, when to push, and when to escalate.
In high-stakes claims, policy limits can define the ceiling or open doors to pursuing more creative paths to full compensation.
Leave a Reply